1600 doesn't equate to genius in my book either. Several of my friends got 1590s. One got a 1600. Ok, the 1600 guy was a genius, but he was way smarter than the 1590 people who are way smarter than me.
I guess it all depends on your reference point. I went to a nerd high school so maybe my definition of genius is far beyond what other people consider to be genius.