Now that all the opinions are out of the way! Lets get input from someone who has had or has both spoilers...who could that be??? Oh me! Go for #2 if you want to be a M5 look-a-like...my self personally got rid of my #2 and got me something similar to #1(mine sits flush..the one in the picture is ugly).....It sets my car apart from a M5 or a M5 look-a-like(which is basically what my car was....a lookalike). I just got mine put on last weekend and mine happens to be flush with my trunk lid .......@Tool Fan: Shopping cart??? Ummm I dont get it dude......and my car definitely does not look like a shopping cart or overtly ricey(had to put that in there before someone else does and pisses me off) On a quick side note...didnt all this Eurotuning start in....yep Europe? Home of BMW, Audi, VW, Peugot and others??? Before the Japanese tuners started doing what Europeans were doing anyway? Someone correct me or inform me if I am wrong! (p.s. @ BimmerX98: I will post pics of the way my car looks now with the new spoiler and window spoiler within the next day or so)