I have an early '96 Z3, no roll hoops. For almost a year I have been looking for a decent wind deflector. BavAuto has a mesh type one. My dealer also has one, but not in stock, the would need to order it. I'm hoping that someone who has one will someday post pics and source info, so I can decide if I really want to do it (I think installation involves cutting some holes, so once it's installed, it's there to stay).